| Year | Date | Opponent | Us | Them | Result | W | L | T | OT | Where | Location | Field | Coach | Notes |
| 1998 | 10/2 | Princeton | 21 | 8 | W | 1 | Away | Princeton | Anne S. Hunnicutt Stadium | David Walker | ||||
| 2004 | 9/24 | Princeton | 56 | 36 | W | 1 | Away | Princeton | Anne S. Hunnicutt Stadium | David Walker | ||||
| 2015 | 9/11 | Princeton | 35 | 21 | W | 1 | Away | Princeton | Anne S. Hunnicutt Stadium | David Walker | ||||
| 2016 | 9/9 | Princeton | 60 | 0 | W | 1 | Home | Martinsburg | Cobourn Field | David Walker | ||||
| 2023 | 12/2 | Princeton | 57 | 13 | W | 1 | Neutral | Wheeling | Wheeling Island Stadium | David Walker | championship at Wheeling | |||
| 229 | 78 | 5 | 0 | 0 | 1.000 | |||||||||
| 45.80 | 15.60 | 30.20 | ||||||||||||