Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1976 11/20 Parkersburg 0 38 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field Bob Kamensky playoff at Martinsburg
2001 12/1 Parkersburg 17 28 L   1     Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium David Walker championship at Wheeling
2004 11/26 Parkersburg 31 28 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2006 12/2 Parkersburg 6 34 L   1     Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium David Walker championship at Wheeling
2018 11/17 Parkersburg 49 20 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2024 11/23 Parkersburg 77 7 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
                             
      180 155   3 3 0 .500          
      30.00 25.83 4.17