Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1928 11/24 Morgantown 6 34 L   1     Home Martinsburg Lambert Field George O. Mullin  
1929 11/22 Morgantown 0 6 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field George O. Mullin  
1930 10/11 Morgantown 0 19 L   1     Home Martinsburg   Ison Shreve  
1931 10/9 Morgantown 12 25 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field Marshall "Little Sleepy" Glenn  
1932 10/8 Morgantown 7 7 T     1   Home Martinsburg Lambert Field Marshall "Little Sleepy" Glenn  
1950 9/8 Morgantown 6 0 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field John Cobourn  
1951 9/14 Morgantown 6 14 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field John Cobourn  
1952 9/12 Morgantown 6 13 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field John Cobourn  
1953 9/18 Morgantown 7 13 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field John Cobourn  
1954 9/17 Morgantown 6 0 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field John Cobourn  
1955 9/16 Morgantown 0 25 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field John Cobourn  
1956 9/14 Morgantown 6 18 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field John Cobourn  
1957 9/13 Morgantown 6 7 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field John Cobourn  
1958 9/12 Morgantown 13 20 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field John Cobourn  
2001 11/23 Morgantown 19 8 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker playoff at Morgantown
2004 12/4 Morgantown 12 38 L   1     Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium David Walker championship at Wheeling
2007 8/24 Morgantown 0 1 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker forfeit - original score 29-3
2009 11/13 Morgantown 19 13 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2010 11/27 Morgantown 24 10 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2011 9/16 Morgantown 33 0 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2011 11/26 Morgantown 38 14 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2012 9/14 Morgantown 56 28 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker  
2013 9/27 Morgantown 28 21 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2014 9/26 Morgantown 30 26 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker  
2015 9/25 Morgantown 17 16 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2016 9/23 Morgantown 33 6 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker  
2016 11/25 Morgantown 51 0 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2017 9/22 Morgantown 51 7 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2017 11/10 Morgantown 61 0 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2022 11/11 Morgantown 42 14 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field Britt Sherman playoff at Martinsburg
2024 10/11 Morgantown 51 14 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker  
2025 10/10 Morgantown 34 6 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2025 12/5 Morgantown 21 28 L   1     Neutral Charleston Laidley Field David Walker championship at Charleston
2026 10/9 Morgantown 24 7 W 1       Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field David Walker  
                             
      725 458   19 14 1 .574          
      21.32 13.47 7.85