Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1998 11/13 Huntington 13 19 L   1     Away Huntington Bob Sang Stadium David Walker playoff at Huntington
2003 11/22 Huntington 21 7 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2011 11/19 Huntington 46 7 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2013 12/7 Huntington 9 7 W 1       Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium David Walker championship at Wheeling
2021 12/4 Huntington 62 21 W 1       Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Britt Sherman championship at Wheeling
2022 11/26 Huntington 21 28 L   1     Away Huntington Bob Sang Stadium Britt Sherman playoff at Huntington
2023 11/25 Huntington 49 26 W 1       Away Huntington Bob Sang Stadium David Walker playoff at Huntington
2024 9/6 Huntington 47 15 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker  
2024 12/7 Huntington 35 34 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2025 9/5 Huntington 20 22 L   1     Away Huntington Bob Sang Stadium David Walker  
                             
      323 186   7 3 0 .700          
      32.30 18.60 13.70