Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1981 11/13 Brooke 0 30 L   1     Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field Bob Kamensky playoff at Martinsburg
1982 11/20 Brooke 0 28 L   1     Neutral Buckhannon Cebe Ross Field Bob Kamensky playoff at Buckhannon
2006 11/11 Brooke 49 7 W 1       Home Martinsburg Cobourn Field David Walker playoff at Martinsburg
2010 12/11 Brooke 30 0 W 1       Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium David Walker championship at Wheeling
                             
      79 65   2 2 0 .500          
      19.75 16.25 3.50