| Year | Date | Opponent | Us | Them | Result | W | L | T | OT | Where | Location | Field | Coach | Notes | |
| 1997 | 10/31 | Columbus DeSales, OH | 0 | 21 | L | 1 | Away | Columbus | Alumni Stadium | Terry Depew | |||||
| 2014 | 11/1 | Columbus DeSales, OH | 7 | 33 | L | 1 | Home | Wheeling | Fawcett Field | B. J. Depew | |||||
| 2015 | 10/30 | Columbus DeSales, OH | 12 | 41 | L | 1 | Away | Columbus | Alumni Stadium | B. J. Depew | |||||
| 2023 | 9/8 | Columbus DeSales, OH | 17 | 30 | L | 1 | Home | West Liberty | West Family Stadium | B. J. Depew | |||||
| 2024 | 9/13 | Columbus DeSales, OH | 13 | 49 | L | 1 | Away | Columbus | Alumni Stadium | B. J. Depew | |||||
| 49 | 174 | 0 | 5 | 0 | .000 | ||||||||||
| 9.80 | 34.80 | 25.00 |