Year Date Opponent PF PA Result W L T OT Where Site Stadium Coach Notes
1984 11/9 Stonewall Jackson 7 14 L   1     Away Charleston Laidley Field Homer Criddle playoff at Charleston
1988 11/11 George Washington 15 0 W 1       Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Homer Criddle playoff at Fairlea
1988 11/18 Huntington 53 21 W 1       Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Homer Criddle playoff at Fairlea
1988 11/26 Charleston 0 17 L   1     Neutral Morgantown Mountaineer Field Homer Criddle championship at WVU
1990 11/10 Wheeling Park 16 33 L   1     Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Homer Criddle playoff at Fairlea
1991 11/9 Wheeling Park 13 21 L   1     Away Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Homer Criddle playoff at Wheeling
1992 11/14 Barboursville 29 34 L   1     Away Barboursville King Field Homer Criddle playoff at Barboursville
1994 11/12 North Marion 14 43 L   1     Away Farmington Husky Stadium Homer Criddle playoff at Rachel
1996 11/15 Bridgeport 19 7 W 1       Away Bridgeport Wayne Jamison Field Bob McClintic playoff at Bridgeport
1996 11/22 Morgantown 12 31 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field Bob McClintic playoff at Morgantown
1997 11/14 Parkersburg 0 29 L   1     Away Parkersburg Stadium Field Bob McClintic playoff at Parkersburg
1998 11/13 Buckhannon-Upshur 7 13 L   1     Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Bob McClintic playoff at Fairlea
2015 11/13 Martinsburg 28 47 L   1     Away Martinsburg Cobourn Field Ray Lee playoff at Martinsburg
2018 11/9 Ripley 15 43 L   1     Away Ripley Memorial Stadium Ray Lee playoff at Ripley
2019 11/15 Spring Mills 27 28 L   1     Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Ray Lee playoff at Fairlea
2021 11/12 George Washington 7 21 L   1     Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Ray Lee playoff at Fairlea
2025 11/14 Chapmanville 37 46 L   1     Home Fairlea Spartan Stadium Ray Lee playoff at Fairlea
                             
      299 448   3 14 0 .176          
      17.59 26.35 -8.76