Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
2002 11/23 Martinsburg 14 36 L   1     Away Martinsburg Cobourn Field Steve Edwards, Jr. playoff at Martinsburg
2011 12/3 Martinsburg 27 35 L   1     Neutral Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Steve Edwards, Jr. championship at Wheeling
2012 11/23 Martinsburg 14 63 L   1     Away Martinsburg Cobourn Field Steve Edwards, Jr. playoff at Martinsburg
2016 11/18 Martinsburg 0 34 L   1     Away Martinsburg Cobourn Field Steve Edwards, Jr. playoff at Martinsburg
2020 11/13 Martinsburg 0 62 L   1     Away Martinsburg Cobourn Field Steve Edwards, Jr. playoff at Martinsburg
                             
      55 230   0 5 0 .000          
      11.00 46.00 -35.00