Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Place Coach Notes  
1980 10/31 Toronto, OH 0 31 L   1     Away Toronto Toronto Stadium Jim Thomas    
1981 11/6 Toronto, OH 12 20 L   1     Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Terry Edwards    
1992 9/11 Toronto, OH 21 20 W 1     1OT Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
1993 9/10 Toronto, OH 20 21 L   1   1OT Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
1994 9/9 Toronto, OH 7 22 L   1     Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
1995 9/8 Toronto, OH 34 6 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
1996 9/6 Toronto, OH 13 0 W 1       Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
1997 9/5 Toronto, OH 13 18 L   1     Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
1998 10/23 Toronto, OH 14 35 L   1     Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
1999 10/16 Toronto, OH 13 27 L   1     Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
2000 10/13 Toronto, OH 12 33 L   1     Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
2001 10/13 Toronto, OH 32 18 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
2002 10/11 Toronto, OH 40 8 W 1       Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
2003 10/10 Toronto, OH 42 15 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Thomas    
2004 10/15 Toronto, OH 62 22 W 1       Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Jim Thomas    
2005 10/15 Toronto, OH 34 12 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Mike Young    
2006 10/13 Toronto, OH 38 28 W 1       Away Toronto Clark Hinkle Field Mike Young    
2007 10/13 Toronto, OH 62 6 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Mike Young    
2024 10/25 Toronto, OH 29 27 W 1       Away Toronto Clarke Hinkle Field Mike Young    
                               
      498 369   11 8 0 .579            
      26.21 19.42 6.79