Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1991 11/30 Wheeling Park 15 14 W 1     1OT Home Charleston Laidley Field Roger Jefferson championship at Charleston
2014 11/22 Wheeling Park 35 14 W 1       Home Charleston Laidley Field Jon Carpenter playoff at Charleston
2015 12/5 Wheeling Park 15 23 L   1     Away Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jon Carpenter championship at Wheeling
2017 11/10 Wheeling Park 63 21 W 1       Home Charleston Laidley Field Jon Carpenter playoff at Charleston
2019 11/15 Wheeling Park 45 21 W 1       Away Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jon Carpenter playoff at Wheeling
                             
      173 93   4 1 0 .800          
      34.60 18.60 16.00