Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1996 11/29 Morgantown 56 7 W 1       Home Charleston Laidley Field Roger Jefferson playoff at Charleston
1998 11/27 Morgantown 0 7 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field Moe Townson playoff at Morgantown
2008 11/22 Morgantown 0 21 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field Jack Woolwine, Jr. playoff at Morgantown
2010 11/19 Morgantown 12 28 L   1     Away Morgantown Pony Lewis Field Jon Carpenter playoff at Morgantown
2018 11/9 Morgantown 42 0 W 1       Home Charleston Laidley Field Jon Carpenter playoff at Charleston
                             
      110 63   2 3 0 .400          
      22.00 12.60 9.40