Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes
1921 11/5 Magnolia 0 30 L   1     Away New Martinsville   Smith  
1925 11/14 Magnolia 0 13 L   1     Away New Martinsville   Chief Gehring  
1926 11/13 Magnolia 1 0 W 1       Home Warwood Garden Park Chief Gehring forfiet - original score 7-26
1933 10/21 Magnolia 0 7 L   1     Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Bob Roe  
1937 10/22 Magnolia 0 14 L   1     Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Bob Roe  
1948 10/22 Magnolia 20 7 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Doug Stone  
1949 10/21 Magnolia 21 0 W 1       Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Earl Gaylor  
1950 10/20 Magnolia 33 6 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Earl Gaylor  
1951 10/19 Magnolia 32 19 W 1       Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Earl Gaylor  
1952 10/17 Magnolia 7 14 L   1     Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Howard Lewellen  
1953 10/23 Magnolia 28 0 W 1       Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Howard Lewellen  
1954 10/23 Magnolia 0 7 L   1     Home Warwood Garden Park Howard Lewellen at Garden Park due to Island flooding
1955 10/21 Magnolia 6 39 L   1     Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Howard Lewellen  
1956 10/20 Magnolia 13 7 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Howard Lewellen  
1957 10/18 Magnolia 38 0 W 1       Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Jim Foti  
1958 10/18 Magnolia 13 6 W 1       Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Foti  
1959 10/23 Magnolia 0 13 L   1     Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Jim Foti  
1960 10/20 Magnolia 14 39 L   1     Home Wheeling Wheeling Island Stadium Jim Foti  
1961 10/20 Magnolia 7 38 L   1     Away New Martinsville Alumni Field Jim Foti  
                             
      233 259   9 10 0 .474          
      12.26 13.63 -1.37