| Year | Date | Opponent | Us | Them | Result | W | L | T | OT | Place | Location | Field | Coach | Notes |
| 1985 | 8/31 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 24 | 0 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Hoosier Dome | Steve Klonne | ||||
| 1986 | 8/29 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 6 | 3 | W | 1 | Home | Kings Mills | Galbreath Field | Steve Klonne | ||||
| 2007 | 10/12 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 31 | 14 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | Bob Crable | |||||
| 2008 | 10/10 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 18 | 21 | L | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Nippert Stadium | John Rodenberg | ||||
| 2010 | 10/1 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 10 | 35 | L | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | John Rodenberg | |||||
| 2011 | 10/14 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 24 | 26 | L | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Roettger Memorial Stadium | John Rodenberg | ||||
| 2012 | 10/12 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 48 | 13 | W | 1 | Away | Indianapolis | John Rodenberg | |||||
| 2013 | 10/18 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 35 | 14 | W | 1 | Home | Lockland | Roettger Memorial Stadium | John Rodenberg | ||||
| 2015 | 8/28 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 21 | 19 | W | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Nippert Stadium | John Rodenberg | ||||
| 2019 | 8/31 | Indianapolis Cathedral, IN | 0 | 28 | L | 1 | Home | Cincinnati | Tom Ballaban Field | Todd Naumann | ||||
| 217 | 173 | 6 | 4 | 0 | .600 | |||||||||
| 21.70 | 17.30 | 4.40 | ||||||||||||