Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes  
1993 11/12 Cincinnati CAPE 21 31 L   1     Neutral Xenia Cox Field Paul Jenne playoff at Xenia  
1997 11/8 Valley View 7 40 L   1     Neutral Xenia Cox Field Paul Jenne playoff at Xenia  
2001 11/3 Wyoming 21 49 L   1     Away Cincinnati   Barry Blackstone playoff at Cincinnati  
2002 11/1 Clinton Massie 21 7 W 1       Home Plain City   Barry Blackstone playoff at Plain City  
2002 11/8 Kettering Alter 7 35 L   1     Neutral Spingfield Panther Stadium Barry Blackstone playoff at Springfield  
2003 11/1 Mariemont 14 28 L   1     Away Cincinnati   Barry Blackstone playoff at Cincinnati  
2004 11/5 Finneytown 35 21 W 1       Home Plain City   Barry Blackstone playoff at Plain City  
2004 11/12 Reading 35 7 W 1       Neutral Xenia Cox Stadium Barry Blackstone playoff at Xenia  
2004 11/19 Versailles 28 35 L   1     Neutral Dayton Welcome Stadium Barry Blackstone playoff at Dayton  
2005 11/5 Blanchester 49 14 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Barry Blackstone playoff at Plain City  
2005 11/12 Lemon-Monroe 7 16 L   1     Neutral Xenia Cox Stadium Barry Blackstone playoff at Xenia  
2006 11/3 Oakwood 55 7 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Steve Coate playoff at Plain City  
2006 11/10 Lemon-Monroe 38 17 W 1       Neutral Clayton Dudon Memorial Field Steve Coate playoff at Clayton  
2006 11/17 Blanchester 17 0 W 1       Neutral Kettering Fairmont Roush Stadium Steve Coate playoff at Kettering  
2006 11/24 Oak Harbor 24 7 W 1       Neutral Lima Lima Senior High School Steve Coate playoff at Lima  
2006 12/1 Cardinal Mooney 12 26 L   1     Neutral Massillon Paul Brown Tiger Stadium Steve Coate championship at Massillon  
2007 11/3 Coldwater 14 43 L   1     Home Plain City Volunteer Field Steve Coate playoff at Plain City  
2008 10/31 Oakwood 10 12 L   1     Home Plain City Volunteer Field Steve Coate playoff at Plain City  
2009 11/7 Kettering Alter 0 42 L   1     Away Kettering   Steve Coate playoff at Kettering  
2010 11/5 Waynesville 45 23 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Steve Coate playoff at Plain City  
2010 11/12 Kettering Alter 14 28 L   1     Neutral Troy Memorial Stadium Steve Coate playoff at Troy  
2011 11/4 Logan Elm 35 21 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Steve Coate playoff at Plain City  
2011 11/11 Jackson 28 7 W 1       Neutral Logan Logan Chieftan Stadium Steve Coate playoff at Logan  
2011 11/18 Shawnee 10 21 L   1     Neutral Hilliard Bradley High School Steve Coate playoff at Hilliard  
2015 11/7 Kenton Ridge 28 33 L   1     Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2016 11/4 Bishop Hartley 21 35 L   1     Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2017 11/3 Clinton Massie 7 17 L   1     Away Clarksville   Brett Glass playoff at Clarksville  
2019 11/8 Sheridan 35 13 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2019 11/15 Jackson 38 13 W 1       Neutral Ashville   Brett Glass playoff at Ashville  
2019 11/22 Bishop Hartley 14 27 L   1     Neutral Hilliard Darby High School Brett Glass playoff at Hilliard  
2020 10/16 Zanesville 35 0 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2020 10/24 London 14 0 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2020 10/30 Columbus DeSales 6 31 L   1     Away Columbus Alumni Stadium Brett Glass playoff at Columbus  
2021 10/29 Eastmoor Academy 7 35 L   1     Away Columbus   Nathan Snedecker playoff at Columbus  
2022 10/28 Tri-Valley 10 30 L   1     Away Dresden Jack Anderson Stadium Nathan Snedecker playoff at Dresden  
2023 10/27 Bishop Ready 10 14 L   1     Away Obetz Fortress Field Nathan Snedecker playoff at Columbus  
2024 11/1 Bishop Ready 17 18 L   1     Away Columbus   Nathan Snedecker playoff at Columbus  
2025 11/7 Johnstown 42 21 W 1       Home Plain City Volunteer Field Brett Glass playoff at Plain City  
2025 11/14 Indian Valley 28 47 L   1     Away Gnadenhutten Brotherhood Stadium Brett Glass playoff at Gnadenhutten  
                               
      859 871   16 23 0 .410            
      22.03 22.33 -0.31