Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes  
1963 9/21 Malvern 0 40 L   1     Away Malvern   Glenn Snyder    
1964 9/26 Malvern 8 52 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Glen Bower    
1965 9/25 Malvern 14 21 L   1     Away Malvern   Glen Bower    
1966 9/24 Malvern 0 30 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Ray Altier    
1967 9/23 Malvern 0 64 L   1     Away Malvern   Ray Altier    
1968 11/2 Malvern 20 46 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Ray Altier    
1969 11/1 Malvern 6 18 L   1     Away Malvern   Donn Foutz    
1970 9/26 Malvern 6 22 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Donn Foutz    
1971 9/25 Malvern 8 30 L   1     Away Malvern   Vern Marlatt    
1972 9/30 Malvern 0 13 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Vern Marlatt    
1973 9/29 Malvern 9 30 L   1     Away Malvern   Randy Miller    
1974 9/20 Malvern 12 15 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Randy Miller    
1975 9/20 Malvern 6 0 W 1       Away Malvern   Randy Miller    
1976 10/15 Malvern 22 6 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Randy Miller    
1977 10/15 Malvern 0 14 L   1     Away Malvern   Jerry Porteus    
1978 10/13 Malvern 6 14 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Matt Mottice    
1979 10/13 Malvern 30 0 W 1       Away Malvern   Matt Mottice    
1980 10/3 Malvern 44 6 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Matt Mottice    
1981 10/10 Malvern 14 8 W 1       Away Malvern   Matt Mottice    
1982 10/8 Malvern 6 29 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Todd Gerber    
1983 10/8 Malvern 20 21 L   1     Away Malvern   Bob Geiger    
1984 10/5 Malvern 6 13 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Bob Geiger    
1985 10/5 Malvern 34 0 W 1       Away Malvern   Bob Geiger    
1986 10/3 Malvern 14 26 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Bob Geiger    
1987 10/3 Malvern 7 0 W 1       Away Malvern   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1988 9/29 Malvern 30 0 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1989 9/30 Malvern 12 25 L   1     Away Malvern   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1990 9/27 Malvern 23 19 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1991 9/28 Malvern 7 14 L   1     Away Malvern   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1992 10/23 Malvern 28 8 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1993 10/23 Malvern 24 20 W 1       Away Malvern   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1994 10/21 Malvern 34 8 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Don Hertler, Jr.    
1995 10/21 Malvern 28 0 W 1       Away Malvern   David Carroll    
1996 10/18 Malvern 39 6 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   David Carroll    
1997 10/18 Malvern 7 26 L   1     Away Malvern   David Carroll    
1998 10/23 Malvern 20 21 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Bryan Ashkettle    
1999 10/16 Malvern 7 41 L   1     Away Malvern   Matt Mottice    
2000 10/13 Malvern 6 26 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Matt Mottice    
2001 10/13 Malvern 22 14 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2002 10/11 Malvern 19 7 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2003 10/4 Malvern 40 20 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2004 9/17 Malvern 26 27 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2005 9/16 Malvern 35 6 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2006 9/29 Malvern 42 19 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2007 9/28 Malvern 39 36 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2008 10/10 Malvern 28 62 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2009 10/16 Malvern 29 44 L   1     Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2010 9/17 Malvern 21 41 L   1     Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2011 9/16 Malvern 22 26 L   1     Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2012 9/14 Malvern 35 32 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2013 10/4 Malvern 34 42 L   1     Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2014 10/3 Malvern 41 8 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2015 10/16 Malvern 49 7 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2016 10/14 Malvern 54 8 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2017 9/22 Malvern 43 12 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2018 9/21 Malvern 28 0 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
2021 9/17 Malvern 30 7 W 1       Away Malvern   Jason Wallick    
2024 9/20 Malvern 41 8 W 1       Home Sugarcreek   Jason Wallick    
                               
      1,235 1,158   28 30 0 .483            
      21.29 19.97 1.33