| Year | Date | Opponent | Us | Them | Result | W | L | T | OT | Where | Location | Field | Coach | Notes | |
| 1995 | 11/11 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 24 | 6 | W | 1 | Neutral | Chillicothe | Herrnstein Field | Mark Crabtree | playoff at Chillicothe | ||||
| 2019 | 9/14 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 55 | 6 | W | 1 | Home | Lancaster | Fulton Field | Doug Miller | |||||
| 2021 | 9/4 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 10 | 35 | L | 1 | Home | Lancaster | Fulton Field | Luke Thimmes | |||||
| 2022 | 9/2 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 0 | 55 | L | 1 | Away | Portsmouth | Spartan Municipal Stadium | Luke Thimmes | |||||
| 2023 | 9/2 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 17 | 46 | L | 1 | Home | Lancaster | Fulton Field | Luke Thimmes | |||||
| 2024 | 9/7 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 31 | 16 | W | 1 | Away | Portsmouth | Spartan Municipal Stadium | Luke Thimmes | |||||
| 2025 | 9/6 | Portsmouth Notre Dame | 6 | 34 | L | 1 | Home | Lancaster | Fulton Field | Luke Thimmes | |||||
| 143 | 198 | 3 | 4 | 0 | .429 | ||||||||||
| 20.43 | 28.29 | -7.86 | |||||||||||||