Year Date Opponent US Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes  
1995 11/10 Celina 25 37 L   1     Away Troy Memorial Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Troy  
1997 11/7 Beechcroft 19 18 W 1       Neutral Springfield Evans Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Springfield  
1997 11/14 St. Francis DeSales 23 41 L   1     Neutral Upper Arlington Memorial Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Upper Arlington  
1998 11/14 St. Francis DeSales 7 24 L   1     Neutral Springfield Evans Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Springfield  
1999 11/5 St. Francis DeSales 20 0 W 1       Away Columbus Alumni Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Columbus  
1999 11/12 Bath 35 28 W 1       Neutral Lima Lima Senior High School Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Lima  
1999 11/19 Bishop Watterson 28 31 L   1     Neutral Dublin Coffman High School Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Dublin  
2000 11/4 Bishop Watterson 13 27 L   1     Away Columbus Hagley Field Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Columbus  
2001 11/2 Willard 7 27 L   1     Home Bellefontaine Dodd Stadium Greg Peitsmeyer playoff at Bellefontaine  
2007 11/2 Shelby 7 35 L   1     Home Bellefontaine Dodd Stadium Jason Brown playoff at Bellefontaine  
2009 11/6 Bishop Watterson 0 26 L   1     Away Columbus Hagley Field Jason Brown playoff at Columbus  
2014 11/7 Bellbrook 13 18 L   1     Home Bellefontaine   Toby Smith playoff at Bellefontaine  
2017 11/3 Granville 55 28 W 1       Home Bellefontaine   Toby Smith playoff at Bellefontaine  
2017 11/10 Tri-Valley 30 36 L   1   1OT Neutral Westerville Warhawk Field Toby Smith playoff at Westerville  
2020 10/9 Columbus South 18 44 L   1     Away Columbus   Jason Brown playoff at Columbus  
2021 10/29 Tri-Valley 20 13 W 1       Away Dresden Jack Anderson Stadium Jason Brown playoff at Dresden  
2021 11/5 Western Brown 20 50 L   1     Away Mount Orab Kibler Stadium Jason Brown playoff at Mount Orab  
2022 10/28 Granville 20 25 L   1     Away Granville Walter J. Hodges Stadium Jason Brown playoff at Granville  
2023 10/27 John Glenn 49 7 W 1       Home Bellefontaine   Jason Brown playoff at Bellefontaine  
2023 11/3 London 35 28 W 1       Away London Bowlus Field Jason Brown playoff at London  
2023 11/10 Granville 29 21 W 1       Neutral London Bowlus Field Jason Brown playoff at London  
2023 11/17 Bishop Watterson 13 19 L   1     Neutral Marion Harding Stadium Jason Brown playoff at Marion  
2024 11/1 Chaminade-Julienne 28 44 L   1     Home Bellefontaine   Jason Brown playoff at Bellefontaine  
                               
      514 627   8 15 0 .348            
      22.35 27.26 -4.91