Year Date Opponent Us Them Result W L T OT Where Location Field Coach Notes  
1954 9/17 Circleville 20 6 W 1       Home Athens Rufus Putnam Field George Riser    
1955 9/16 Circleville 0 19 L   1     Away Circleville   George Riser    
1956 9/14 Circleville 13 7 W 1       Away Circleville   George Riser    
1957 9/13 Circleville 19 0 W 1       Home Athens Rufus Putnam Field Don Eskey    
1958 9/12 Circleville 14 18 L   1     Away Circleville   Don Eskey    
1959 9/18 Circleville 18 6 W 1       Home Athens Rufus Putnam Field Don Eskey    
1960 9/16 Circleville 32 0 W 1       Away Circleville   Don Eskey    
1961 9/15 Circleville 2 15 L   1     Home Athens Rufus Putnam Field Don Eskey    
1962 9/14 Circleville 8 16 L   1     Away Circleville   Don Eskey    
1971 11/12 Circleville 21 8 W 1       Away Circleville   Gerald Inbody    
1972 11/10 Circleville 15 7 W 1       Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field Gerald Inbody    
1973 9/21 Circleville 22 8 W 1       Away Circleville   Les Walker    
1974 9/20 Circleville 7 21 L   1     Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field Les Walker    
1975 9/19 Circleville 0 13 L   1     Away Circleville   Les Walker    
1976 9/25 Circleville 12 20 L   1     Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field Les Walker    
1977 9/23 Circleville 15 0 W 1       Away Circleville   Les Walker    
1978 9/22 Circleville 3 0 W 1       Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field John Murray    
1979 9/21 Circleville 0 6 L   1     Away Circleville   John Murray    
1980 9/12 Circleville 0 7 L   1     Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field John Murray    
1981 9/18 Circleville 0 35 L   1     Away Circleville   Doug Hoyer    
1982 9/17 Circleville 0 37 L   1     Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field Les Champlin    
1983 9/16 Circleville 7 33 L   1     Away Circleville   Rick Smith    
1984 9/14 Circleville 8 30 L   1     Home The Plains R. Basil Rutter Field Rick Smith    
2012 11/3 Circleville 63 28 W 1       Home The Plains Scott Riggs and Family Stadium Ryan Adams playoff at The Plains  
                               
      299 340   11 13 0 .458            
      12.46 14.17 -1.71